Here Are the Best Restaurants in Egg Harbor

One of the most important aspects of any vacation is deciding where you’ll eat! Luckily, when you stay with us at The Ashbrooke, plenty of delectable dining options are nearby! Whether you’re hungry for a hearty breakfast, delicious lunch, or a fine dining experience, you’ll find the perfect place to delight your taste buds. These are just a few of our favorite nearby Egg Harbor restaurants that we’re sure you’ll love just as much as we do! 

Looking for more to do in Door County, WI? You can request access to our free Vacation Guide for insight into the best restaurants, fun activities, and year-round events that await you on Lake Michigan’s coast! Get the guide and start planning your getaway today!

OUR FREE VACATION GUIDE

The Best Egg Harbor Restaurants You Have To Try

Village Cafe

Village Cafe is an artsy eatery that offers everything you need for an enjoyable meal. Great food, a fun atmosphere, a refreshing beer, a wine list, and a homemade dessert menu add to a perfect experience. Their carrot cake is to die for, the food is always fresh and delicious, and all the artwork displayed in the shop is available for you to take home! 

The Fireside Restaurant

Marrying New Orleans Cajun cuisine with a Midwestern down to earth vibe, The Fireside Restaurant is a local favorite for good reasons. A TripAdvisor Travelers’ Choice Award winner, Fireside is open for good vibes, food, and service Thursday – Monday after 4 p.m. We recommend lobster/andouille hushpuppies to start and the jambalaya for your main course!  

Casey’s BBQ & Smokehouse

For a taste of top-notch barbeque, head to Casey’s BBQ & Smokehouse. This casual barbeque joint concocts mouthwatering Southern flavors by smoking their meats with cherry wood for a mild smoky flavor. Try one of their specialty pulled pork sandwiches or prime rib platters. The highlights of the show are Casey’s BBQ plates, especially the baby-back ribs.

Other Nearby Door County Restaurants

Chives Restaurant (Baileys Harbor)

When you’re visiting Door County, and you want to treat yourself to a mind-blowing meal, you must try the Chives in Baileys Harbor. This fine dining establishment emphasizes its farm-to-table roots with a mix of locally grown and sourced ingredients.  Located at Baileys Harbor, Chives is less than 15 minutes from The Ashbrooke Hotel and has everything you need for the perfect date night.  

Old Post Office Fish Boil (Ephraim)

The Old Post Office Fish Boil is a Wisconsin tradition unlike any other. A fish boil is a traditional Scandinavian style of cooking large catches of fish. The boil is focused on a large pot over an open flame with fresh-caught whitefish native to Scandinavian waters.  

Wisconsin’s large amount of Scandinavian immigrants has given the Old World technique a New World twist. The Old Post Office Restaurant has been dishing out fish from Lake Michigan since 1874 and the waterfront views are simply hard to pass up. Make sure to visit on Monday through Saturday during the evening to witness the fish boil. 

The Shiny Moon Café (Fish Creek)

Occupying the space formerly held by Mr. Helsinki, The Shiny Moon Café has replaced the iconic Mr. Helsinkis with a positive spin on comfort food. The Fish Creek restaurant has a breakfast and lunch menu with stars such as the Duck Confit Hash and Kalua Pork Sandwich. Open Thursday – Monday, expect an incredible pick me up to continue your day. 

Alexander’s of Door County (Fish Creek)

If you’re looking for a place for a romantic date night with your special someone, Alexander’s is a perfect choice. This elegant dining experience takes you on a fantastic culinary journey, with a menu featuring premium cuts of meat, fresh seafood, and other great selections. Start your meal with succulent shrimp tempura or savory baked artichoke gorgonzola. For your main course, enjoy a tender steak or local broiled Door County whitefish. Finish off your special night with a slice of decadent warm chocolate cake or delicate tiramisu. Alexander’s also holds a classy champagne brunch every Sunday. 

Wild Tomato (Fish Creek & Sister Bay)

The Wild Tomato is the best place to eat pizza in Egg Harbor. Their menu has an assortment of salads, sandwiches, and specialty wood-fired pies. We are a big fan of the delicious veggie pizza piled high with fresh veggies that will send your taste buds to the moon! You can also create your own yummy pizza creation from their extensive list of locally grown ingredients. 

Experience All That Door County Has To Offer at the Ashbrooke Hotel

Beyond grabbing a meal at one of the best Door County restaurants, there’s so much more to discover on Lake Michigan’s coast. That’s why you should make the Ashbrooke Hotel your home-away-from-home on your next getaway! Our luxurious accommodations feature only the best amenities that make your stay as comfortable as possible. Whether you’re sampling the many beautiful places to eat, exploring the enchanting wilderness, or just relaxing with your loved one, there is something for everyone to enjoy in Door County. 

Check our availability to start planning your trip today! For more information on the best things to do and places to see, request your free Vacation Guide!

CHECK AVAILABILITY